A Montessori Mother — Inside the Classic

(0 User reviews)   3102
In Category - Teaching Methods
Fisher, Dorothy Canfield, 1879-1958 Project Gutenberg 2019 Not confirmed
Montessori method of education Readers of public-domain and historical texts
Project Gutenberg digital edition en

Edition facts

Words 69,238
Reading time 302 min
Text sections 22

This digital edition of A Montessori Mother — Inside the Classic is described by source-level measurements including 69,238 words, 5 hr 2 min estimated reading time, and 22 detected text sections.

The text analysis averages about 28.9 words per sentence, while the detected sections provide another way to judge how the source is divided.

Project Gutenberg metadata also associates the work with “Montessori method of education,” connecting these edition facts with the source record’s subject description.

Dorothy Canfield Fisher recounts her firsthand observations of Montessori schools in Rome and her close interactions with Maria Montessori, addressing common parental doubts and contrasting the method with traditional child-rearing. The book blends travel narrative, psychological insight, and practical guidance for American mothers.
Share
Editorial Edition Score 4.9/5

Calculated from edition completeness, EPUB availability, text structure and catalogue metadata. Not a user rating.

How this score is calculated
  • Description quality20 pts
  • Title & short description10 pts
  • Source metadata20 pts
  • Text length15 pts
  • Chapters / structure15 pts
  • EPUB file integrity20 pts

Total of 100 points, scaled to a 2.5-5.0 range. Editions with an empty description or a missing EPUB file are not scored.

Edition quality

Read the Text

These were painted in alternate stripes of red and blue, these stripes being the same width as the shortest rod. The children were putting these together in consecutive order so as to make a sort of series, and although they were evidently much too young to count, they were aiding themselves by touching with their fingers each of the painted stripes, and verifying in this way the length of the rod. I could not follow this process, although it was plainly something arithmetical, and turned to ask the teacher about it.

I saw her across the room engaged in tying a bandage about a child’s eyes. Wondering if this were some new, scientific form of punishment, I stepped to that part of the room and watched the subsequent proceedings. The child, his lips curved in an expectant smile, even laughing a little in pleasant excitement, turned his blindfolded face to a pile of small pieces of cloth before him. Several children, walking past, stopped and hung over the edge of his desk with lively interest. The boy drew out from the pile a piece of velvet. He felt of this intently, running the sensitive tips of his fingers lightly over the nap, and cocking his head on one side in deep thought. The child-spectators gazed at him with sympathetic attention. When he gave the right name, they all smiled and nodded their heads in satisfaction. He drew out another piece from the big pile, coarse cotton cloth this time, which he instantly recognized; then a square of satin over which his little finger-tips wandered with evident sensuous pleasure. His successful naming of this was too much for his envious little spectators. They turned and fled toward the teacher and when I reached her, she was the center of a little group of children, all clamoring to be blindfolded.

“How they do love that exercise!” she said, looking after them with shining eyes ... I could have sworn, with mother’s eyes!

“Are you too busy and hurried,” I asked, “to explain to me the game those children are playing with the red and blue rods?”

She answered with some surprise, “Oh, no, I’m not busy and hurried at all!” (quite as though we were not all living in the twentieth century) and went on, “The children can come and find me if they need me.”

So I had my first lesson in the theory of self-education and self-dependence underlying the Montessori apparatus, to the accompaniment of occasional requests for aid, or demands for sympathy over an achievement, made in clear, baby treble. That theory will be taken up later in this book, as this chapter is intended only to be a plain narration of a few of the sights encountered by an ordinary observer in a morning in a Montessori school.

After a time I noticed that four little girls were sitting at a neatly-ordered small table, spread with a white cloth, apparently eating their luncheons. The teacher, in answer to my inquiring glance at them, explained that it was their turn to be the waitresses that day, for the children’s lunch, and so they ate their own meal first.

She was called away just then, and I sat looking at the roomful of busy children, listening to the pleasant murmur of their chats together, watching them move freely about as they liked, noting their absorbed, happy concentration on their tasks. Already some of the sense of the miraculous which had been so vivid in my mind during my first survey of the school was dulled, or rather, explained away. Now that I had seen some of the details composing the picture, the whole seemed more natural. It was not surprising, for instance, that the little girl sorting the pieces of money should not instead be pulling another child’s hair, or wandering in aimless and potentially naughty idleness about the room. It was not necessary either to force or exhort her to be a quiet and untroublesome citizen of that little republic. She would no more leave her fascinating occupation to go and “be naughty” than a professor of chemistry would leave an absorbing experiment in his laboratory to go and rob a candy-store. In both cases it would be leaving the best sort of a “good time” for a much less enjoyable undertaking.

Dorothy Canfield Fisher opens A Montessori Mother not with a dry pedagogical treatise but with a vivid scene of homecoming. Returning from a prolonged stay in Rome, she finds herself besieged by family, friends, and even strangers demanding an account of the Montessori schools. The questions are strikingly similar: Is it a fad? Do children really do as they please? Can it work for American families? Fisher’s preface establishes the book as a direct response to these urgent, often misdirected inquiries, positioning herself as a witness who saw the schools firsthand and enjoyed close personal relations with Dr. Montessori herself.

The Reluctance to Let Children Grow Up

Fisher does not shy away from uncomfortable self-scrutiny. In a passage that draws on the sardonic essayist Hazlitt, she dissects the hidden egotism in a mother’s cry, “Oh, I can’t bear to have the babies grow up!” She confesses she once felt that way herself, and now recognizes it as a desire to continue in a “self-assumed rôle of God,” surrounded by little sycophants who cannot judge her. The language is deliberately sharp: she speaks of “almost unadulterated egotism” and a wish to keep children “weak and dependent” to feed her own pride. This psychological honesty sets the stage for Montessori’s alternative—a mother-love that is “infinitely more searching and subtle,” one that advances into the “harder battle against the hidden, treacherous ambushes of egotism.”

From Rome to the American Home

The book’s structure mirrors Fisher’s own journey: she moves from describing the Roman schools to addressing the practical concerns of American mothers. The excerpts show her fielding questions about whether Montessori “spoils” children or “stimulates them unnaturally.” She does not offer a simple yes or no. Instead, she uses the contrast between Italian and American contexts to explore deeper principles. The reader is invited to see the method not as a fixed curriculum but as a shift in attitude—away from the benevolent tyranny of traditional parenting and toward a respect for the child’s own activity. Fisher’s tone is conversational yet incisive, as if she is still talking from the appearance of the coffee-cups till a very late bedtime.

The Hazlitt Interlude and the Tyranny of Benefits

One of the most striking features of the excerpts is Fisher’s extended quotation from William Hazlitt, in which he derides benefactors who keep their protégés perpetually dependent. Hazlitt’s voice—biting, ironic—is allowed to speak for nearly a paragraph: “You are not haled ashore … you are required … to be always swimming in troubled waters.” Fisher then applies this to mothers, arguing that the instinct to be the stronger, to be looked up to, is alive in all of us. The inclusion of Hazlitt is unusual for a parenting manual; it signals that Fisher is writing for an educated audience and is unafraid to borrow from literary tradition to make her point. This interlude also reveals her own intellectual range, weaving together travelogue, psychology, and literary criticism into a single argument.

Readers approaching A Montessori Mother should expect a hybrid work: part memoir of Fisher’s Roman sojourn, part psychological exposé of parental motives, and part practical introduction to Montessori principles. The book does not provide a step-by-step guide to the didactic materials; instead, it offers a rationale for why those materials matter. Fisher’s voice is direct, self-critical, and occasionally literary. Those who come looking for a dry manual will be surprised; those who want to understand the spirit behind the method will find a candid and thought-provoking companion.

I kept thinking about how Dorothy Canfield Fisher watched Montessori let children find their own pace, trusting them to grow quietly. It reminded me of another woman who trusted young minds—Elizabeth missing? No, Dorothea Beale did, too. Her life felt like that same patient faith in education, a slow unfolding. Dorothea Beale: Principal of the Cheltenham Ladies' College, 1858-1906 — Story, Setting & Ideas stays with me that way, soft and steady.

There are no reviews for this eBook.

0
0 out of 5 (0 User reviews )

Add a Review

Your Rating *
There are no comments for this eBook.

Reader reflection

How did this book work for you?

Your answers remain private and are stored only in this browser.

Your progress 0 / 10
1

Where are you in your reading?

2

How much did you enjoy the reading experience?

3

Would you pass this book on to a friend?

4

What was the reading difficulty like?

Related eBooks